: Conversely, critics at The Singles Jukebox and Kyle's Korner found the lyrical metaphors, such as "salt and sugar," to be awkward or even "creepy". Some felt the "sensual" attempt felt unconvincing for Chesney's established persona. Kenny Chesney's New Song 'Tip of My Tongue' - Rolling Stone
The song's production is characterized by a "sweeping groove" and a "decidedly grown-up" feel. Kenny Chesney - Tip Of My Tongue (Audio)
: Chesney had the title idea "Tip of My Tongue" for a long time but didn't know how to execute it until he collaborated with Sheeran and Copperman. : Conversely, critics at The Singles Jukebox and